Bhagol
HomeEssays › The wanderers

The wanderers

वक्रानुवक्रम् · ग्रहयुद्धम् · अष्टधा गतिः · नवग्रहाः

The fixed stars keep their promises — the first essay was about how much the texts built on that. The planets do not. Five lights wander against the star-road, speed up, slow down, stand still, and — most scandalously — go backwards, each in its own rhythm. Sanskrit has one word for the outrage, vakra, 'bent', and this essay follows that one word through every register the corpus owns: the war-omen, the battlefield simile, the observer's catalogue, the omen-book's own quiet demolition, and the taxonomy that finally makes the backward loop just one speed among eight.

Every quote is a slice from Jñānakośa, the research database behind this atlas; each links to its revision-pinned source page. Translations are literal renderings; dates are approximate spans of compilation. Display markup of the e-texts is removed here; the full text, apparatus and confidence grades are one click away.

The bend and the return-bend

वक्रानुवक्रम् · the loop as portent

Before Kurukṣetra, the Bhīṣma-parva's omen catalogue — the same one that carries the thirteen-day fortnight of the eclipse essay — reads Mars's full retrograde loop as a portent, and reads it precisely: the loop named as a single gesture (vakrānuvakram, 'the bend and the return-bend'), the star-station given, and the planet standing at the turn:

Mahābhārata 6.3.18 (vulgate) · c. 4th c. BCE – 4th c. CE
वक्रानुवक्रं कृत्वा च श्रवणं पावकप्रभः । ब्रह्मराशिं समावृत्य लोहिताङ्गो व्यवस्थितः ।।
And having made the bend and the return-bend (vakrānuvakram), the fire-bright red-limbed one stands, enveloping Brahmarāśi, at Śravaṇa.

Planet, loop, station: everything a modern astronomer needs to identify the configuration is in the line — which is why these verses are the raw material of every attempt to date the war, a debate the database records without joining.

See: the omen catalogue's eclipses, in essay three

Like the red planet returning

अङ्गारक इव ग्रहः · common property

Two parvans later the same loop appears with no portent attached at all. Arjuna fights his way out, turns, and comes back shining — and the poet reaches for the sky's best-known comeback. A simile only works if the audience already knows the image; by the epic's day, Mars's out-and-back was common cultural property:

Mahābhārata 8.55.1 (vulgate) · c. 4th c. BCE – 4th c. CE
प्रत्येत्याथ पुनर्जिष्णुर्जित्वा संशप्तकान्बभौ। वक्रानुवक्रगमनादङ्गारक इव ग्रहः।।
Then Jiṣṇu [Arjuna], having conquered the saṃśaptakas, came back again and shone — like the planet Aṅgāraka from his bent-and-returning course.

The loop, catalogued

भौमचार · the observer's ledger

Varāhamihira's Mars-course chapter opens with the loop already systematized: the retrograde is indexed by how far the planet has travelled from its heliacal rising — the ninth, eighth, or seventh asterism, roughly 90–120 degrees of elongation, which is in fact the band where Mars's retrograde begins. An empirical regularity, filed in omen dress:

Bṛhat-saṃhitā 6.1 · 6th c. CE
यद्युदयऋक्षाद्वक्रं करोति नवमाष्टसप्तमऋक्षेषु । तद्*वक्त्राम्[क्.वक्रं ऊ.वक्त्रम्] उष्णं उदये पीडाकरं अग्निवार्त्तानाम् ।। ६.०१ ।।
If, [counting] from the asterism of his rising, he makes his retrograde in the ninth, the eighth, or the seventh asterism, that [retrograde], hot at its rising, brings affliction upon fire-workers and news-bearers(?).

The cāra chapters keep this ledger for every planet — Saturn's stations among the nakṣatras fed the Rohiṇī omens of the first essay. The omen register, here as everywhere, is where the positional data was archived.

Wars of the line of sight

ग्रहयुद्धम् · the war dissolved

When two wanderers close on each other, the omen tradition sees a war — and Varāhamihira opens his planet-war chapter by quietly dissolving it. The planets stand each on its own path, one above the other; they only 'come as if to sameness' in the observer's field of sight because the distances are so great. Conjunction as perspective across depth-ordered orbits — stated first, before a single portent is read, with the computation referred to 'my karaṇa, the Sūrya-siddhānta' and the war-taxonomy politely credited to the older school of Parāśara:

Bṛhat-saṃhitā 17.1–3 · 6th c. CE
युद्धं यथा यदा वा *भविष्यम्[क्.भविष्यद्] आदिश्यते त्रिकालज्ञैः । तद्विज्ञानं करणे मया कृतं सूर्य*सिद्धान्ते[क्.सिद्धान्तात्] ।। १७.०१ ।। वियति चरतां ग्रहाणां उपर्युपर्यात्ममार्गसंस्थानाम् । अतिदूराद्दृग्विषये समतां इव सम्प्रयातानाम् ।। १७.०२ ।। आसन्नक्रमयोगाद्भेदौल्लेखांशुमर्दन*असव्यैः[क्.असव्यः] । युद्धं चतुष्प्रकारं पराशरऽद्यैर्मुनिभिरुक्तम् ।। १७.०३ ।।
How, and when, a coming war [of planets] is declared by the knowers of the three times — the science of computing it I have made in my karaṇa, the Sūrya-siddhānta. Of the planets moving in the sky, standing each on its own path, one above the other, come as if to sameness in the field of sight because of the very great distance — [of these] the war is of four kinds, by nearness of approach: piercing (bheda), grazing (ullekha), the clash of rays, and the left-hand passage — so it was taught by Parāśara and the [other] sages.

Eight speeds, one demand

अष्टधा गतिः · the machine

The siddhānta supplies the machine. The movers are invisible 'embodiments of Time' stationed on the star-circle — śīghrocca, mandocca, pāta — hauling the planets by cords of wind:

Sūrya-siddhānta 2.1–3 · c. 5th–8th c. CE
अदृश्यरूपाः कालस्य मूर्तयो भगणाश्रिताः । शीघ्रमन्दोच्चपाताख्या ग्रहाणां गतिहेतवः ।। २.०१ ।। तद्वातरश्मिभिर्*बद्धास्तैस्सव्येतरपाणिभिः । (C नद्धास्) प्राक्पश्चादपकृष्यन्ते यथासन्नं स्वदिङ्मुखम् ।। २.०२ ।। प्रवहाख्यो मरुत्तांस्तु स्वोच्चाभिमुखं ईरयेत् । पूर्वापराकृष्टास्ते *गतिं यान्ति पृथग्विधाः ।।(C गतीर्, पृथग्विधाम्) २.०३ ।।
Invisible in form, embodiments of Time, stationed on the circle of asterisms — called śīghrocca, mandocca, and pāta — are the causes of the planets' motion. Bound to them by cords of wind, [the planets] are drawn by their left and right hands eastward and westward, toward wherever [the puller] stands nearest. And the wind called pravaha drives them toward their own uccas; drawn east and west, they take on their manifold motions.

And under that mythic dress, the honest engineering: motion is eightfold — two bent speeds and six straight ones, a taxonomy in which retrograde is not an anomaly but a named gear — and the whole correction procedure exists, says the text, 'so that the planets come to agreement with what is seen' (dṛk-tulyatā), the same clause the trepidation chapter closes on:

Sūrya-siddhānta 2.12–14 · c. 5th–8th c. CE
*वक्रातिवक्रा विकला मन्दा मन्दतरा समा । (C वक्रानुवक्रा) तथा शीघ्रतरा शीघ्रा ग्रहाणां अष्टधा गतिः ।। २.१२ ।। तत्रातिशीघ्रा शीघ्राख्या मन्दा मन्दतरा समा । ऋज्वीति पञ्चधा ज्ञेया *या वक्रा सातिवक्रगा ।।(C +अन्या वक्रादिका मता) २.१३ ।। तत्तद्गतिवशान्नित्यं यथा दृक्तुल्यतां ग्रहाः । प्रयान्ति तत्प्रवक्ष्यामि स्फुटीकरणं आदरात् ।। २.१४ ।।
Vakrā ('bent back'), ativakrā ('deeply bent') [the apparatus reads anuvakrā], vikalā ('failing'), mandā ('slow'), mandatarā ('slower'), samā ('even'), and likewise śīghratarā ('swifter') and śīghrā ('swift') — eightfold is the motion of the planets. Among these, the very-swift, the swift-named, the slow, the slower, and the even are to be known as the fivefold straight motion; the one that is vakrā goes over into ativakrā. And so that the planets perpetually come, by each such motion, to agreement with observation (dṛk-tulyatām), I shall declare the true-correction (sphuṭīkaraṇa) with care.

Behind both stands Āryabhaṭa's ledger of revolutions — the yuga counts that turn every wandering into arithmetic, packed into his alphabet-code (attested in the database at Gītikā 2–3, along with the earth's own 1,582,237,500 eastward turns).

See: the trepidation chapter's same closing clause, in essay two

Ants on the potter's wheel

कुलालचक्र · two motions at once

Why is the wanderers' motion so hard to read? The Bhāgavata's cosmography answers with the corpus's best physics image. Ants crossing a spinning potter's wheel have two motions at once — the wheel's, and their own — and are found at ever different places on it; so the planets, carried by the wheel of the sky, still creep along paths of their own. Relative motion, decomposed on a household instrument:

Bhāgavata-purāṇa 5.22.2 · c. 500–1000 CE
yathā kulālacakreṇa bhramatā saha bhramatāṃ tadāśrayāṇāṃ pipīlikādīnāṃ gatir anyaiva pradeśāntareṣv apy upalabhyamānatvād evaṃ nakṣatrarāśibhir upalakṣitena kālacakreṇa dhruvaṃ meruṃ ca pradakṣiṇena paridhāvatā saha paridhāvamānānāṃ tadāśrayāṇāṃ sūryādīnāṃ grahāṇāṃ gatir anyaiva nakṣatrāntare rāśyantare copalabhyamānatvāt // bhp_05.22.002 //
Just as, for ants and such creatures mounted on a turning potter's wheel and turning with it, the motion is truly their own besides — since they are found at ever different places [on the wheel] — so, for the planets beginning with the sun, which run around Dhruva and Meru keeping them to the right, carried along by the wheel of time marked out by the nakṣatras and the rāśis, the motion is truly their own besides — since they are observed in ever different nakṣatras and different rāśis.

The roster of nine

नवग्रहाः · nine chairs at the fire

And the ritual register seats them all at one fire. The navagraha roster runs the two luminaries and the five true wanderers in the weekday order — and then adds Rāhu and Ketu, the beheaded eclipse-demon's head and trunk, really the moon's two nodes, enrolled as planets with chairs of their own. Every mover of the sky, visible or geometric, propitiated in one rite:

Agni-purāṇa 164.1–2 · c. 700–1100 CE
श्रीकामः शान्तिकामो वा ग्रहयज्ञं समारभेत् ।१६४.००१ वृष्ट्यायुःपुष्टिकामो वा तथैवाभिचरन् पुनः ॥१६४.००१ सूर्यः सोमो मङ्गलश्च बुधश्चाथ बृहस्पतिः ।१६४.००२ शुक्रः शनैश्चरो राहुः केतुश्चेति ग्रहाः स्मृताः ॥१६४.००२
One desiring fortune or peace — or rain, long life, and prosperity, or likewise one working rites against another — should undertake the graha-sacrifice. Sun, Moon, Maṅgala, Budha, and then Bṛhaspati, Śukra, Śanaiścara, Rāhu, and Ketu: these are held to be the grahas.

See: how Rāhu earned his chair, in essay three

One word, four registers

Follow vakra once more across the shelf: an omen-reader logs the bend-and-return with its station; a poet assumes every listener knows the red planet's comeback; a saṃhitā indexes the loop by elongation and dissolves planet-wars into line-of-sight geometry — citing its author's own computing manual as it does; a siddhānta files the backward motion as two named speeds among eight and demands the result agree with the eye; and a purāṇa hands the whole company — nodes included — chairs at the sacrificial fire. The wanderers were never tamed by any one register. They were tamed by all of them holding, together, everything the loop is: a sign, an image, a record, a geometry, and a guest.

Each quote carries its full citation, edition, revision-pinned source link and confidence grading in Jñānakośa — batch graha-vakra-pass1 with the standing astronomy passes. The five wanderers are in the sky tonight, each at its own speed — one of them may be mid-loop right now; the companion app will show you which.